Hiring a professional to paint the exterior of your home may seem like a straightforward task. After all, it’s just paint, right? But the truth is, exterior painting is an investment in your home’s longevity, curb appeal, and value. Making the wrong choice—or skipping key steps—can lead to peeling paint, wasted money, or even damage to your property. To help you navigate the process wisely, here are the top seven mistakes homeowners commonly make when hiring an exterior house painter, and how to avoid them.
1. Prioritizing Price Over Quality
It’s tempting to go with the lowest quote, especially when home improvement costs quickly add up. But when it comes to exterior painting, cheaper often doesn’t mean better. Bargain pricing can be a red flag for rushed jobs, subpar materials, or untrained labour. While it’s important to stick to your budget, be wary of choosing a painter solely because they’re the cheapest. Instead, look for a fair, detailed estimate that clearly outlines prep work, materials, coats of paint, and cleanup.
A quality painter for exterior of home should offer transparent pricing without vague or hidden costs. It’s always better to invest a bit more upfront than to deal with premature fading, cracking, or having to repaint a few years down the line.
2. Failing to Check Insurance and Licensing
This is one of the most overlooked yet critical steps in the hiring process. If the painter isn’t properly insured and licensed (as required by local regulations), you could be liable for damages or injuries that occur on your property. It’s not enough to take their word for it—always request proof of liability insurance and, if applicable, workers’ compensation coverage.
Not only does this protect you financially, but it also shows the painter operates professionally and takes their business seriously. A reputable contractor will have no problem sharing this documentation.
3. Skipping the References and Reviews
Even if a painter comes recommended, always dig a little deeper. Check online reviews on platforms like Google, HomeStars, or Houzz, and ask for recent references. Speaking directly to past clients can give you insight into reliability, cleanliness, attention to detail, and whether the final result matched expectations.
Be especially cautious if you see patterns of complaints—such as delays, poor communication, or unfinished work. A few negative reviews aren’t unusual, but how the company responds to those reviews can also be telling.
4. Not Getting a Detailed Written Contract
A handshake or vague verbal agreement just won’t cut it. Without a detailed contract, you have no recourse if expectations aren’t met. The agreement should include start and end dates, the type and brand of paint being used, surface preparation methods, number of coats, payment schedule, and cleanup responsibilities.
Also be sure to clarify whether the painter will handle minor repairs (e.g., wood rot, caulking, or pressure washing) before painting begins. A written contract ensures everyone is on the same page and reduces the risk of misunderstandings later.
5. Ignoring Prep Work
The prep phase is arguably more important than the paint itself. Neglecting proper preparation—like sanding, scraping old paint, cleaning mildew, or priming raw surfaces—can cause the new paint job to fail prematurely. Yet some painters cut corners here to save time.
Ask detailed questions about how they prepare different exterior surfaces such as wood, stucco, brick, or siding. A well-prepared surface will ensure your new paint adheres correctly and lasts for years. If the painter glosses over this step, it’s a red flag.
6. Overlooking Warranty Terms
A reputable painter should stand behind their work with a warranty that covers both materials and labour. But not all warranties are created equal. Some may only apply to the paint (and be issued by the manufacturer), while others may not cover issues that arise from improper application.
Ask what the warranty includes, how long it lasts, and what situations might void it. Make sure it’s included in writing in your contract. A solid warranty is a sign the painter is confident in their craftsmanship and will address any issues if they arise down the line.
7. Neglecting to Match the Painter’s Experience with Your Project Type
Exterior painting isn’t a one-size-fits-all service. A painter with experience in high-rise buildings may not be the best fit for a century-old detached home with wood siding. Ask about their specific experience with your type of exterior material and architectural style.
If your home has unique requirements—like heritage preservation guidelines, complex trim work, or intricate surfaces—choose a painter who has tackled similar projects. This helps ensure a seamless, lasting finish that enhances your home’s character rather than detracting from it.
Investing in the Right Painter Saves More Than Just Time
Hiring the right professional for your exterior painting job isn’t just about enhancing your curb appeal—it’s about protecting your home from the elements, preserving its value, and ensuring peace of mind. By avoiding these common missteps, you’re far more likely to find a skilled, reliable painter who delivers results you’ll love for years.
When in doubt, trust your instincts and do your research. Your home deserves the best—and so do you.
